23-25 Settembre 2004

filosofia analitica e cultura europea

FORM FOR THE REFEREES dowload the form in .doc format or dowload the form in .pdf format

YOU NEED TO GIVE AT LEAST YOUR "LAST IMPRESSION"
OTHER COMMENTS ARE HIGLY WELCOME

Abstract Number:

Abstract Title:

Last impression - choose one of theese categories:

1. surely reject
2. tend to reject
3. uncertain
4. tend to accept
5. very positive
6. surely accept

OPTIONAL PART

Suggestions for the referees (you may give yes/no answers)

1. Does the title clearly and sufficiently reflect its content?
2. Is this a new and original contribution?
3. Is the abstract long enough or clear enough to make its point? (*)
4. Are the presentation and organization satisfactory?
5. Are the interpretations/conclusions sound and justified by the data?
5. Is the quality of the English/Italian satisfactory?
6. Is the abstract acceptable / with minor revisions?
-----
(*) we have given 5000 characters, which is a fairly short space, but enough to make a point in short.

You are welcome to give general comments or specific suggestion
(Use as mush space as you like)

PART TO BE READ BY THE ORGANIZATORS OF THE CONFERENCE:

PART TO BE READ BY THE AUTHOR: