Brains, Persons, and Society *** FORM FOR THE REFEREES
Cervelli, Persone e Società *** CRITERI DI SELEZIONE



 

dowload the form in .doc format
or
dowload the form in .pdf format

YOU NEED TO GIVE A CLEAR "LAST IMPRESSION"
OTHER COMMENTS ARE HIGLY WELCOME

Abstract Number:

Abstract Title:

Last impression - choose one of theese categories:

1. surely reject
2. tend to reject
3. uncertain
4. tend to accept
5. very positive
6. surely accept

OPTIONAL PART

Suggestions for the referees (you may give yes/no answers)


1. Does the title clearly and sufficiently reflect its content?
2. Is this a new and original contribution?
3. Is the abstract long enough or clear enough to make its point? (*)
4. Are the presentation and organization satisfactory?
5. Are the interpretations/conclusions sound and justified by the data?
5. Is the quality of the English/Italian satisfactory?
6. Is the abstract acceptable / with minor revisions?
-----
(*) we have given 5000 characters, which is a fairly short space, but enough to make a point in short.

You are welcome to give general comments or specific suggestion
(Use as mush space as you like)

PART TO BE READ BY THE ORGANIZATORS OF THE CONFERENCE:




PART TO BE READ BY THE AUTHOR: